The short answer
No. Alcohol slows fat burning for a few hours after you drink, not for 48 hours, and at a drink or two the research doesn't show the muscle loss people claim. Drinking slows fat loss through what happens around it: you tend to eat more, sleep worse, and move less the next day, and each of those gets bigger the more you drink. If you choose to drink, keep it to one drink for most women and two for most men, and finish your last one at least three hours before bed.
What the research actually shows
- The 37% muscle number comes from young, active men who had about eight or nine drinks after a hard workout. Their muscle building over the next several hours dropped 37%, or about 24% if they also had protein.
- The same lab found no effect at two or three drinks. Five or six drinks after a hard workout slowed how fast strength came back over the next two to three days.
- In one study, less than two drinks reduced fat burning by about 73% for several hours, because your body burns the alcohol first. Less than a gram of it turned into body fat, and nobody has measured fat burning staying off for 48 hours.
- When researchers pooled lab studies, people who had alcohol before a meal ate about 80 more calories of food. With the drink itself, that came to roughly 250 extra calories.
- A large review of sleep lab studies found that REM sleep starts dropping at around two drinks, and it drops more the more you drink. In a large study of working adults wearing heart rate monitors, the body's recovery during the first few hours of sleep dropped even with one drink.
- In a large study of women in their 40s and early 50s, about one drink a day was tied to roughly double the odds of bothersome hot flashes and night sweats compared with women who never drank. It's a link, not proof of cause and effect.
If you choose to drink, these rules help you keep losing fat
| How many | Stop at one drink for most women and two for most men on a given night. Count a 5-ounce glass of wine, a 12-ounce beer, or a shot as one drink. |
|---|---|
| When | Finish your last drink at least three hours before bed. If you go to bed at 10:00, your last drink is at 7:00, and after that you can switch to seltzer or something non-alcoholic. |
| With food | Eat a real meal with 30-40 grams of protein before or with your drinks. |
| Around training | Keep heavier drinking away from your hardest training, and don't plan to go after a PR the next morning. |
| Every time | Log your alcohol like any other food. In an app like MacroFactor, pick an entry that shows the alcohol grams, since many entries list it as carbs. |
Free 14-day guide
Build the 2 habits that make fat loss work
A daily protein target and 3 to 4 strength sessions a week, with a simple tracker. No calorie counting or hours of cardio.
Chapters
- 0:00Alcohol myths before the holidays
- 5:17A daily plan that adjusts to your sleep and recovery
- 6:40The 37 percent muscle study
- 9:30Does alcohol stop fat burning?
- 11:07Drinking and how much you eat
- 12:51Alcohol, REM sleep, and moving less the next day
- 15:43Perimenopause, hot flashes, and alcohol
- 18:514 rules for drinking and fat loss
- 23:47Bonus: a 2-week test for night sweats
Questions from this episode
Does alcohol stop fat burning for 48 hours?
No. It slows fat burning for a few hours, because your liver turns most of the alcohol into acetate and your body burns that before it goes back to burning fat. Your fat loss still comes down to your total calories over the week, including the calories from your drinks.
Does a drink after training stop you from building muscle?
A drink or two doesn't. The 37% drop came from about eight or nine drinks after a hard workout, and the same lab found no effect at two or three drinks. Heavy drinking after training does slow your recovery.
How many drinks can you have and still lose fat?
My answer is one for most women and two for most men on a given night. Two drinks is about where the muscle research stops finding harm and where the sleep research starts to find it, and the split between women and men is mostly based on the size difference.
Why does drinking slow fat loss if it doesn't stop fat burning?
It affects three things: how much you eat, how well you sleep, and how much you move the next day. Each of those gets bigger the more you drink.
When should you have your last drink?
Finish it at least three hours before bed. That's roughly the time it takes to clear one or two drinks, and in a study using wearable data, people who drank earlier in the evening slept with less disruption.
Is red wine good for you?
No. I don't recommend drinking for your health. Less is better, and the old claims about red wine and resveratrol no longer hold up.
Mentioned in this episode
More episodes on nutrition for lifters over 40 →
About the host. Philip Pape is a certified nutrition coach and the host of Wits & Weights, a top 1% podcast on strength training and nutrition for adults over 40, with 500+ episodes and over a million downloads. Educational content only, not medical advice.
Transcript
Alcohol Myths Before The Holidays
Philip Pape0:00
If you've got holiday parties coming up and you've heard that alcohol stops fat burning for days and keeps you from building muscle, this episode is for you. Today I'm evaluating those alcohol claims. You'll learn how much you'd have to drink before it affects your muscle, what drinking does to your eating and your sleep, and how many drinks I'd have and when to keep losing fat.
Show Mission And What We Test
Philip Pape0:27
Welcome to Wits & Weights, the show that puts a popular piece of fitness advice under the microscope, finds the hidden reason it doesn't work, and gives you the deceptively simple fix that does. I'm your host, certified nutrition coach Philip Pape, and this episode comes out about 10 days before Thanksgiving here in the US, which means for a lot of you, the next six weeks are going to include more drinks than usual. You've got work parties, family dinners, maybe a glass of wine because your in-laws in town and this is when you drink, and you've probably heard that alcohol has a negative impact on fat. It could stop fat burning for 48 to 72 hours, that one drink stops your muscles from growing, or that alcohol is the reason for things like menopause belly. And some of that is partly true, some of it is wrong. So today I want to separate those, and then you can decide based on uh how much you drink instead of you know being overly afraid of things that don't impact you, even though my big caveat when it comes to alcohol is less is better, there's really no good amount. Um, it is a toxin. I will say that, but even I occasionally enjoy a drink here and there. So it's it's up to you. It's your choice. Uh just understand the implications. So I'm not gonna tell you to quit drinking. I'm not gonna tell you that, you know, red wine is healthy for you either. You know, being 46 myself, I grew up in a time where there were, for a while, maybe a decade, maybe more, claims that things like resveratrol and red wine are good for you to some level. And really, that is absolutely not the case anymore. So if you're not up to date on the science, that is where we stand today. And there may be even worse effects from alcohol. And again, not to fear monger, but we need to look at the evidence and how it's evolved over time. Now, if you heard or watched episode 506 on sleep, probably heard because uh we weren't doing much video until now. Going forward, we're gonna have our all of our episodes on video on all the platforms on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, as well as audio. But anyway, episode 506 on sleep uh today connects to that quite well because for a lot of you, sleep is where alcohol makes the biggest difference. And then toward the end of the episode, I'm gonna give you a two-week test, especially if you're in perimenopause, if you're uh ladies who enjoy the show, that's based on a study where about one drink a day was tied to roughly double the odds of bothersome hot flashes and night sweats.
Where The Claims Come From
Philip Pape2:46
So for today's episode, we're gonna first look at the claims, including the muscle study that a lot of the claims happen to come from. Uh, we can we can trace it to just one in particular, how much alcohol was in that study. Then we're gonna talk about what drinking does to your eating, to your sleep, especially for women in perimenopause and menopause, although it affects all of us, as I can tell from my aura ring and how I feel the next day. And then I'll give you a simple rule that you can use at the next party where, you know, you just can't avoid the fact that there is lots of alcohol there. All right, let's start with the claims as always because they're everywhere right now. And the one that I see most is that alcohol stops fat burning for 48 hours, sometimes 72 hours. I've also seen 36. So where do those numbers come from? Well, I couldn't find a single study that had all the numbers conveniently, but there is the one about muscle where alcohol cuts muscle building by 37%. So a couple of drinks after you train means, hey, I'm not gonna build any muscle from that workout and it goes to waste. And then there's the you know, Andrew Huberman alcohol episode from a few years back where the takeaway was that the best amount of alcohol to drink is zero. People share that clip all the time. And then there's some truth to that too. So, to be fair, the official advice has also changed in that time. This past January, the new U.S. dietary guidelines got rid of the old numbers. Uh, for decades, you could drink up to two drinks a day for men, one for women. And now it says, hey, just drink less. That's better. Less is better. Canada, on the other hand, now says no more than two drinks on any one occasion. So if you're confused, there's a reason for that because the people writing these guidelines don't always agree. There's different countries, sometimes there's politics involved, and sometimes some countries are more aggressive than others in like adapting to the research.
Why The Messaging Gets Extreme
Philip Pape4:34
Now, a lot of people are trying to sell you stuff, whether it's supplements for hangover, liver detox products are all big right now. Uh, sober coaching apps, sober coaching, wearable companies. You know, I have an order ring myself, so I get it. I'm not saying any of this is bad on its face. I'm saying that when someone's telling you something, it's fair to ask if there's a product behind it. You know, my products tend to be related to body composition, fitness, training, nutrition. So for me, alcohol is a number of among a suite of things we have to understand about nutrition, how it affects those, although I don't have anything specific related to alcohol. And speaking of that, in full disclosure, I do have an app called Fitness Lab. It's an AI coaching app that I built for adults over 40 like myself who lift weights, who want to lose fat. And it takes a lot of your data, including, yes, data that is pushed to Apple Health from these other devices like your aura. You know, after you've had a night of alcohol and your HRV and your body temperature and things like that are a little bit off, take all that data, it could take your weight trend and measurements, your sleep, your training, what you're eating, puts it all together, bada bing, bada boom, boop, boop, boop, and it tells you what to do next. It gives you a very simple plan each day. Hey, based on your readiness, your recovery, your progress, your goals, here's maybe the focus for today. Like very low bar, very achievable. Let's get it done, let's establish that routine. So if you say had a couple of late nights, your sleep is off, maybe you had some drinks, it can take that to account into account instead of just looking at something like the scale or just like barreling ahead with here's your plan, here's your next workout. I'm also mentioning it now, it's a good time to try it because my Black Friday sale runs from November 17th through the 27th. This episode comes out on the 16th. And so as a podcast listener, even though the public gets 20% off, you get an exclusive 30% off, whether you're listener or viewer. The link is in the show notes, and that is already live. So that's my gift to you for the holidays. 30% off and only through the 27th, tap the link in the show notes to check out Fitness Lab.
The 37 Percent Muscle Study
Philip Pape6:40
All right, so let's look at where this 37% number comes from related to alcohol. If you're over 40 and you lift weights, you've probably heard that alcohol cuts muscle building by 37%. That number comes from an actual study, but the men in the study drank a lot. So these are young active men that had about eight or nine American drinks after a hard workout, and their muscle building over the next several hours dropped 37%, or about 24%, if they also had protein. In another study, two or three drinks after a hard workout did not change how fast their strength came back. So heavy drinking after training does slow down muscle building, whereas a glass of wine with dinner probably doesn't. And that was a really good group of researchers. Uh, Louise Burke was one of them. She's about as respected as it gets in sports nutrition. So I wouldn't call this a junk study. You know, people like to cherry pick their studies. I get it. I try to synthesize as many as I can together, especially meta-analysis or randomized controlled trials, but there it's just a lot of drinking in a small group of men in their 20s. And the paper mentions 12 standard drinks because Australian drinks are smaller than ours in the US, which is actually kind of surprising to me. Well, I shouldn't go there. And it tells us very little directly about, you know, specific demographics or specific populations, like, okay, 55-year-old women who lift weights, you know, or something like that. The same lab found that no effect of two or three drinks, but they did find five or six drinks. And then after a hard workout that makes you sore for many days, it slowed down how fast your strength came back over the next two to three days. And that's not too surprising if you're gonna have that many drinks. And then there's a 10-week training study where people had one or two drinks a day, and they found the same gains in fitness and lean mass as in people who didn't drink, though, though, that was interval training in young adults. So I think what we're saying is here for muscle, it depends on how much you drink. Now, that's a shocker, right? It depends on how much you drink. Heavy drinking after training does slow your recovery. And at a drink or two, the evidence just doesn't show the harm that people claim. And again, I'm I'm not for drinking more alcohol. I'm for people drinking less, but I also have to be honest about what we can tell from evidence. You know, have people studied trained lifters over 40 that have one or two drinks across many, many months? Probably not. I'm going based on the evidence we have. So that's that piece of it, the muscle piece, you know, whether you want to over or underreact to the data, that's kind of the nuanced view.
Does Alcohol Stop Fat Burning
Philip Pape9:25
What about fat burning? If you're over 40 and trying to lose fat, you've probably heard that alcohol stops fat burning for 48 hours. Uh, it does slow down fat burning, but just for a few hours, not for two days. In one study, less than two drinks reduce fat burning by about 73% for several hours because your body burns alcohol first, but less than a gram of it turned into body fat. And nobody really has measured fat burning staying off for 48 hours. So guess what? Your fat loss still comes down to your total calories over the week. Are you in an energy deficit, including the calories from drinks and alcohol? Now, 73% sounds terrible, doesn't it? But your liver, which is a great detoxifier without the need for detox cleanses, turns most of the alcohol into something called acetate. And then your body burns that before it goes back to burning fat. So it's kind of like a furnace that burns wood, which I'm thinking about because we stack wood here in New England and burn a lot of it. Uh, a furnace that burns wood you just put in before it goes back to using oil, and now the oil is still in the tank, if that makes sense. I don't know how many people have that kind of dual system furnace, but it's with the way I was thinking about it. As far as I can tell, nobody has really tested that. That's that's that's the thing, is this stuff isn't tested and the people claim claim it, which is the problem I have with it. So if a drink or two doesn't stop you from building muscle and it doesn't stop fat burning for days on days, does that mean that alcohol doesn't matter for fat loss? No, of course not. It affects three things, which are how much you eat, how well you sleep, and how much you move the next
Eating More After Drinking
Philip Pape11:09
day. So let's go over those. The first one is how much you eat. If you're trying to lose fat, your drinks actually add more calories than just what's in the glass. Let me explain. When researchers pooled lab studies that gave people an alcoholic or a non-alcoholic drink before meal, guess what? The people who had the alcohol ate about 80 more calories of food, and then with the drink itself came to roughly 250 extra calories. So you essentially are adding the calories from the drink, which is already more, as well as extra calories that you tend to eat due to cravings, due to lack of inhibitions, whatever it is. So strategically, think about having your food first, for example, making sure to log all your calories, and the fact that the more alcohol you drink, the more you're probably going to eat on top of what you would have anyway. So they call this the apetitif effect. I hope I'm saying that right. That is Italian or French word, you know, appetitif that that's used in European cuisine. Your body doesn't count alcohol calories and eat less to make up for them. You probably don't do that either by choice, because you're not thinking as straight after that second or third glass of wine or whiskey or whatever it is. You're probably not thinking of your macros anymore either, or any of that quote unquote discipline you might have thought you had going in. So it's not just the drink, it's the chips and the cheese board and the second plate of food and the bread and everything else that come along with drinking. Tell me if I'm not right on that one. The second factor here is
Sleep Quality Takes The Hit
Philip Pape12:47
sleep. And I think this is the big one. If you heard episode 506, you know I am not someone who panics about getting exactly eight hours of sleep. I think a lot of people can optimize their life on less than that. Many of us need to, have to, whatever way you want to put it, but alcohol significantly changes the quality, the kind of sleep you get. If you are over 40, a drink or two probably affects your sleep more than your metabolism. A large review of sleep lab studies found that REM sleep starts dropping at around two drinks, and it drops more the more you drink. So even though alcohol helps you fall asleep a little faster at higher doses, you wake up more in the second half of the night. It's just not good for your sleep. If you're going to drink, finish your last drink at least three hours before you go to bed. That is my recommendation. It's kind of like caffeine, it's just gonna greatly disrupt your sleep. And we've even seen in a study of wearables, people who drank earlier in the evening slept with less disruption. And in a large study of working adults wearing heart rate monitors, the body's recovery during the first few hours of sleep dropped, even with just one drink, and then it dropped a lot more as the drinks went up and up. So this is highlighting some of the things we've seen lately with the one drink phenomenon. Like even one drink can make a big difference. And look, I anecdotally, personally, I've seen this when I don't drink for weeks or months on end, and then I have just one beer, and all of a sudden I can really feel the effect, the negative effects of it, even if I might have quote unquote enjoyed myself. So that's the second thing is sleep. The third one is how much you move the next day.
Moving Less The Next Day
Philip Pape14:29
So there was this huge set of data from people wearing fitness trackers. I love the fact that fitness trackers allow us to collect so much data, and now we can analyze with AI as well. But in this, in this study, people moved less the day after drinking, and then the more they drank, the less they move. So again, there's a dose response here. Now, this comes from Whoop, the wearable company. So there's there's always a conflict of interest. But I mean, you this tends to be, I'll say, a counterintuitive finding, I would say, and they're sharing their data. So whatever you want to make of it, you know, the the recovery scores that these devices use, whether they're accurate or not, that's a whole different story. But if you've ever had a few drinks and decided that, hey, I'm not gonna go to the gym, you know what I'm talking about, right? So just keep in mind that drinking will affect how much you move or train the next day. So drinking affects fat loss through what happens around it, not by anything magical that it does by shutting down your metabolism. You tend to eat more, you tend to sleep worse, you tend to move less the next day, and each of those increases the more you drink, at least in actual studies that we have of real human
Perimenopause And Alcohol Effects
Philip Pape15:35
beings. So now let's quickly talk about women and especially women in period post-menopause, because first of all, a lot of the research is in young men, I always like to mention that because there are different variables at play here. And yes, a lot of things are universally applicable to humans in general, but there are some specific things that happen with age, with different physiology, with different genders that are worth calling out. So for women, women's bodies tend to respond a little more to each drink. Now, whether that's just on average for body weight or because of body weight, you know what I'm saying? Like because women tend to be on average smaller. But in that same wearable data study that I mentioned earlier, one extra drink raised women's overnight heart rate and lowered their HRV, their heart rate variability, a little more than it did for men. So one drink for you is not the same as one drink for the bigger guy sitting next to you. And again, it could just be a size thing. Second, what about hot flashes, night sweats? In women in their 40s and early 50s, drinking more is linked with more bothersome hot flashes. Now, again, this is correlational, it's a link, it's not proof of cause and effect, it's not necessarily every study that's finding this, but I am going to give you a simple way to test it on yourself at the end of this episode. Teaser. A lot of you are waking up more at night. This is super, super common. And for some of you, it's because of sleep apnea, it's because of stress, because a lot of different things. But the alcohol, like that second glass of wine when you're 45, 50, 55 years old, tends to make your sleep worse than it would have when you had it when you were 25 or 30. And it's not because your metabolism is broken, but because your sleep was probably already getting interrupted the older we get. Am I right? Third, and I'm gonna say this once, and I'm going to keep it in proportion, please. I'm not a medical doctor. I don't dispense medical advice, but this is related to breast cancer. Even moderate drinking is linked with a higher risk of breast cancer. The Surgeon General and the National Academies agree on that now. It's been published as such that's not a fat loss issue. But if you're worried about other negative effects of alcohol, more and more of those effects are being seen now that we have enough data, which goes back to my earlier statement that alcohol is a toxin, there's no good amount of it, less is better. I'm not going to tell you to abstain. I'm not going to tell you how to live your life. I'm just sharing the data. Now, there was a finding in the research that went the other direction. Again, the wearable data research, a lot of good information there. Older adults showed smaller changes from a drink than younger adults did. So the idea that you just can't handle alcohol because you're older, it's not necessarily what the data shows. What does change when we're older is your sleep, your hormones. Sometimes you have a smaller calorie budget to work with for a variety of reasons, right? Your metabolism might be a little bit lower because you don't move as much, because you're more stressed, because you have less muscle mass, etc. All right.
Simple Rules For Party Nights
Philip Pape18:31
So what do you do? This is the deceptively simple part. It's a limit on how many drinks you have. It's having a cutoff time before you go to bed, and then two small habits that I want to share with you. All right, so number one is a limit on how many drinks you have. How many drinks can you have and still lose fat as you get older, over 40? My answer is one for most women, and two for most men on a given night. Two drinks is about where the muscle research stops finding harm, like you know, below that I should say, and then where the sleep research starts to see harm as well. So that's kind of the threshold. The split between women and men is more my judgment, but also based on the size difference, right? Women's heart rate and recovery seems to change a little bit more with each drink based on the research. They tend to be smaller in size, just kind of makes sense. Just like when I talk about fiber requirements, tends to be a little bit less, but it is going to depend on the individual and your own tolerance and things like that. I would count standard drinks, like a five-ounce glass of wine, a 12-ounce beer, or a shot as a drink, because that giant pour or that imperial pint of Guinness that you call a single glass might be closer to two. All right, so that's number one. Number two is to finish your last drink at least three hours before bed. Now, why three? It is roughly the time that it takes to clear from your system one or two drinks. So if you're at a dinner party and you go to bed at 10, your last drink's at seven. I know that doesn't sound that late. If that feels too early, then it maybe tells you something about how much the drinks are affecting your sleep. You know what I'm saying? So you could always switch to a non-alcoholic at that point, to seltzer water, to soda, you know, enjoy that drink early, but then switch out later. It's it's actually going to help you sleep better just having more hydration and water anyway. So think about it. Number three is have protein with the drink. So eat a real meal with your protein, something like 30 to 40 grams before or with the drinks. In the same study about muscle, that drop in muscle building, you remember, was only 24% instead of 30 7% when they had protein, even with all the alcohol. So it's it's a nice buffer to prevent from losing, or it's it's how you keep losing fat, I guess, is to keep that protein high regardless, even when drinks are part of your routine. Number four is to keep your heavier drinking away from your hardest training. Kind of like keeping cardio away from training. Not really. I don't want to equate drink heavy drinking with cardio. I didn't mean to do that. If you're if you're gonna have more than a couple of drinks, don't do it right after your heaviest like leg day session. Don't plan to go after PR the next morning, right? That is when heavier drinking can tend to slow things down and slow strength recovery and you give you more systemic fatigue and all of that jazz. And then, of course, just log your alcohol like any other food. You don't need a detox, you don't need a supplement, you don't have to abstain or quit unless you want to, and it's not a bad idea, but just log it like anything else. For those of you that use an app like MacroFactor, make sure you use a common entry that actually shows the alcohol grams and doesn't a lot of the database entries won't have it as alcohol, they'll have it as just carbs. Now, am I saying alcohol is good for you? No, I hope I didn't say that one time throughout this whole episode. Researchers disagree about whether light drinking helps your heart. And I think the disagreement has gotten almost to a consensus of it doesn't. There, there's smatterings of things that come out occasionally like, oh, but wait, maybe maybe it does. I don't think you should drink for your health, is my point. Now, I'm also not saying you should drink a lot either. Like, even though I'm not saying drinking is, you know, completely the worst thing in the world, I'm not saying, you know, a moderate to high amount of drinking is good either. That's that's where we start to see the harm. You know, if you if you have like eight drinks after you train or like a six pack of beer, like that's gonna be a problem. That's gonna be a problem not just for muscle mass, but for a lot of other things. Right. And I'm also not saying you have to drink it all, okay? If you've cut back and you've cut all the way to zero and you're feeling great, which pretty much happens almost exclusively, keep it up, keep it up. So just to summarize what I've said today, a drink or two earlier in the evening is probably gonna be okay if you're trying to lose fat. But if it's slowing your progress, it's probably through your sleep, probably how much you're eating, you can change these things, you are in control.
Share The Episode And Support
Philip Pape23:02
All right, before we wrap up, I promised you that two-week test for hot flashes and night sweats, ladies. I'm gonna give that to you in just a second. But if you know someone who's about to skip the wine at Thanksgiving because they heard it stops fat burning for two or three days, or if you know someone whose office party turns into a drink-a-thon, share this episode with them. It's the best way to support the show. Like and subscribe if you're on YouTube, follow the show. It's really gonna help us out in reaching more people with these positive, in control, empowering messages, I hope.
Two Week Test For Hot Flashes
Philip Pape23:36
All right, here it is. If you're in perimenopause and you wake up drenched with sweat at three in the morning, and I know some ladies who have that exact thing happen on a regular basis, try a two-week test as follows before you just start blaming hormones and freaking out. All right, in a large study of women in their 40s and early 50s, about one drink a day was tied to roughly double the odds of bothersome hot flashes and night sweats compared with women who never drank. And three or more a day with about three and a half times the odds of those hot flashes and night sweats. So go two weeks with no alcohol at all. Now, if you're already doing this, great, and I'm sorry if you still have hot flashes and there's lots of reasons for that. But try this. Go two weeks with zero alcohol. I want you to note in your journal or just in an app, whatever, each morning, whether you had night sweats and compare that to two normal weeks where you occasionally drink throughout the week. So that's it. That's where I like to take a study, take a snapshot. Maybe it's caused and effect, maybe it's not. Why don't you try it out as an experiment and see? And you might find some other benefits as well.
Key Takeaways And Closing
Philip Pape24:40
Until next time, keep using your wits, lifting those weights, and remember that a drink or two doesn't stop fat burning for days, but it can make you eat more and sleep worse. So set a limit and finish your last drink three hours before bed. I'm Philip Pape, and I'll talk to you next time here on the Wits & Weights Podcast.